Name	Known for
Natasha Hatalsky Detective Christina Elliot Detective Christina Elliot See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Wendy Hartman Detective Rebecca Ellison Detective Rebecca Ellison See fewer	First Signal (2021)
Tony Ramos Wright Father Jacob Hamblin Father Jacob Hamblin See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Kathryn Shasha Agent Cable (credit only) Agent Cable (credit only) See fewer	Sex Drive (2008)
John Samela Chief Hudson Chief Hudson See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Susan Waletkus Detective Penelope Grant (credit only) Detective Penelope Grant (credit only) See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Luisa Maria Badaracco Catherine Hamblin Catherine Hamblin See fewer	Joy (I) (2015)
Jonathan Sartell Dylan Hamblin (credit only) Dylan Hamblin (credit only) See fewer	The Girl in the Attic (2016)
Karen Ann Martino Mother Turner Mother Turner See fewer	The Girl in the Attic (2016)
Charlie Alejandro Elena Maretto Elena Maretto See fewer	Fields of Diamonds
Damon D'Amico Jr. Isaac Isaac See fewer	Slender Man (I) (2018)
Gia Dill Cult Member Cult Member See fewer	The Resurrection of Victoria Wheeler (2020)
Mark Donelan Cult Member Cult Member See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Avery Evans Lilly Elliot Lilly Elliot See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Andrew Faria Patrick Patrick See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Mary C. Ferrara Larissa Larissa See fewer	Schmoopie (2018)
Wendi Elle Flanders Cult Member Cult Member See fewer	Permanent (2014)
Jeff Hatalsky Cult Member Cult Member See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Mary Hronicek Cult Member Cult Member See fewer	Here Lies Joe (2016)
Tilia Jacobs Cult Member Cult Member See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Cathy Joy Cult Member Cult Member See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Judith Maloney Cult Member Cult Member See fewer	Silence (X) (2015)
Nancy Shaprio Cult Member Cult Member See fewer	Family Problems (2013)