Betsy Palmer–
Anne Gaines / Honoria McCord / Julie Bower / Mrs. Lizzie Newberry / Naomi / …
More
Anne Gaines / Honoria McCord / Julie Bower / Mrs. Lizzie Newberry / Naomi / Sue Swales
Less 5,807
9
1954–1960
Richard Kiley–
Charlie Webb / Capt. Kenneth Wilkins / Captain Duggan / Mark Davis / Paul Barman / …
More
Charlie Webb / Capt. Kenneth Wilkins / Captain Duggan / Mark Davis / Paul Barman / Scott Malone
Less 12,618
10
1953–1961
Hans Conried–
Arthur Bannister / Bert Hay / Jean Pierre
Arthur Bannister / Bert Hay / Jean Pierre
Less 5,263
7
1954–1963
Jeff Donnell–
Eva Dulaney / Sadie Merrick / Virginia Purdy
Eva Dulaney / Sadie Merrick / Virginia Purdy
Less 12,114
7
1954–1962
Joseph Sweeney–
Priest / Grandpa / Hugh Follensbee / Tom
Priest / Grandpa / Hugh Follensbee / Tom
Less 28,792
7
1954–1961
Edward Andrews–
Charlie Anders / Eddie / Fred / Fred Purdy / Roger Hilton
Charlie Anders / Eddie / Fred / Fred Purdy / Roger Hilton
Less 7,886
7
1954–1960
Biff McGuire–
Alec GRaham / Gil Wayne / Jack Framer / John Madeira / Kenneth
Alec GRaham / Gil Wayne / Jack Framer / John Madeira / Kenneth
Less 27,917
7
1956–1963
Cathleen Nesbitt–
Cissie Hampshire / Lady Muriel Morrigan / Mrs. Twymeley
Cissie Hampshire / Lady Muriel Morrigan / Mrs. Twymeley
Less 31,303
7
1956–1963
Patty Duke–
Kathy / Penelope / Robin Kent / Sonya Alexandrovna
Kathy / Penelope / Robin Kent / Sonya Alexandrovna
Less 5,002
6
1958–1962
Frank Overton–
Al / Al Durfee / George Crozier / Matt Preston / Mr. Thornton / …
More
Al / Al Durfee / George Crozier / Matt Preston / Mr. Thornton / Steve
Less 23,711
6
1954–1963
Jack Carson–
Enoch McCabe / Harry Steuben / Joey Miller / King / Maxie
Enoch McCabe / Harry Steuben / Joey Miller / King / Maxie
Less 7,602
6
1954–1962
Larry Blyden–
Doc Randolph / Miles Miller / Roger Dinwiddie / Sam Spaulding / Stewart Potter
Doc Randolph / Miles Miller / Roger Dinwiddie / Sam Spaulding / Stewart Potter
Less 30,988
6
1958–1962
Barry Morse–
Jeremy Penlove / Latimore / Older Detective
Jeremy Penlove / Latimore / Older Detective
Less 21,724
6
1958–1961
Robert Lansing–
Jim Walton / Norman Goodhue / Young Doctor
Jim Walton / Norman Goodhue / Young Doctor
Less 17,201
6
1959–1963
Diana Lynn–
Felicia / Francesca / Marie-Louise Voyson / Zepha Wilson
Felicia / Francesca / Marie-Louise Voyson / Zepha Wilson
Less 20,862
5
1954–1961
Nehemiah Persoff–
D'Arnault-Olivier / Ralph Tugwell / Russian diplomat
D'Arnault-Olivier / Ralph Tugwell / Russian diplomat
Less 10,486
5
1955–1958
Faye Emerson–
Dorothy Hilton / Hazel Curtis / Marian Burnett
Dorothy Hilton / Hazel Curtis / Marian Burnett
Less 38,348
5
1953–1961
Heywood Hale Broun–
Bartender / Duffy / Joe Pilver / Spectator
Bartender / Duffy / Joe Pilver / Spectator
Less 174,128
5
1954–1962
Teresa Wright–
Allie Gulliver / Louise Henderson / Margaret Swift / Miss Mary
Allie Gulliver / Louise Henderson / Margaret Swift / Miss Mary
Less 9,151
5
1954–1962
Geraldine Brooks–
Betty Coogan / Gillian Harrison / Vera
Betty Coogan / Gillian Harrison / Vera
Less 11,976
5
1954–1961
June Lockhart–
Edith Sealey / Margaret / Martha Ann / Sally
Edith Sealey / Margaret / Martha Ann / Sally
Less 749
5
1954–1959
Lori March–
Billy / Elinor Deane / Helen Baker / Jean / Mrs. Wakeman
Billy / Elinor Deane / Helen Baker / Jean / Mrs. Wakeman
Less 33,291
5
1954–1958
Alexander Clark–
Bernard / Captain / Dr. Charles / Dr. Waxman
Bernard / Captain / Dr. Charles / Dr. Waxman
Less 452,832
5
1955–1960
Truman Smith–
Ed Ritchie / Judge / Prof. Tillinghast
Ed Ritchie / Judge / Prof. Tillinghast
Less 733,975
5
1956–1963
Peter Mark Richman–
John West / Lieutenant Antonio Ortega / Mark Henderson
John West / Lieutenant Antonio Ortega / Mark Henderson
Less 6,253
5
1956–1962
John McGovern–
Henry Powers / Michael Lockhart / Mr. Asbaugh / Mr. Moors / Y. Lyman Harris
Henry Powers / Michael Lockhart / Mr. Asbaugh / Mr. Moors / Y. Lyman Harris
Less 155,620
5
1956–1961
Ruth White–
Sister St. Anne / Mrs. Botsford / Mrs. Vining / Nettie Bowers
Sister St. Anne / Mrs. Botsford / Mrs. Vining / Nettie Bowers
Less 33,689
5
1958–1963
Gene Hackman–
Ed / Joey Carlton / Reverend MacCreighton / Steve
Ed / Joey Carlton / Reverend MacCreighton / Steve
Less 1,525
5
1959–1962
Glenda Farrell–
Edna Huntington / Grace Smith / Mrs. Rausch
Edna Huntington / Grace Smith / Mrs. Rausch
Less 23,669
5
1960–1963
Lloyd Bochner–
Lord Harton / Peter Cochrane / Philip
Lord Harton / Peter Cochrane / Philip
Less 12,947
5
1961–1963
Cliff Robertson–
Charlie Gordon / Frank / Horace Mann Borden / Mason Stephens
Charlie Gordon / Frank / Horace Mann Borden / Mason Stephens
Less 7,424
4
1956–1961
Fritz Weaver–
Carl Schard / Douglas Oberon / Francis
Carl Schard / Douglas Oberon / Francis
Less 11,623
4
1956–1962
Eddie Albert–
Jordan Blake / Sam Stover
Jordan Blake / Sam Stover
Less 9,711
4
1953–1962
Viveca Lindfors–
Danielle / Mary Lawrence
Danielle / Mary Lawrence
Less 8,800
4
1953–1959
Henderson Forsythe–
Calvin Broderick / Charles Austin / Dr. Bill Ward / Man at Humble & Rockford's
Calvin Broderick / Charles Austin / Dr. Bill Ward / Man at Humble & Rockford's
Less 96,558
4
1954–1963
Nina Foch–
Grace Barlow / Julia Walton
Grace Barlow / Julia Walton
Less 3,385
4
1954–1960
William Harrigan–
Ralph Henry / Father / Father Magner
Ralph Henry / Father / Father Magner
Less 169,836
4
1954–1960
John Beal–
Col. Bill Wheeler / Mr. Hare / Steven Barlow
Col. Bill Wheeler / Mr. Hare / Steven Barlow
Less 42,013
4
1957–1963
Frank McHugh–
Dan O'Malley / George Rausch / Pa Garfield / Tude Bowers
Dan O'Malley / George Rausch / Pa Garfield / Tude Bowers
Less 25,230
4
1957–1963
Ed Begley–
Daniel Arnold / Judge McCord / Walter Kincaid
Daniel Arnold / Judge McCord / Walter Kincaid
Less 12,189
4
1957–1960
Burt Brinckerhoff–
Bud Sullivan / Ed Gandee / Jamie Arnold / Neal
Bud Sullivan / Ed Gandee / Jamie Arnold / Neal
Less 75,649
4
1957–1960
Arthur Hill–
Putnam Bayne Jr. / Robert Howell
Putnam Bayne Jr. / Robert Howell
Less 29,480
4
1958–1962
Donald Moffat–
Captain Stolner / Joe Cartey / Lieutenant Jack Harrison / Younger Detective
Captain Stolner / Joe Cartey / Lieutenant Jack Harrison / Younger Detective
Less 12,242
4
1958–1960
Frank Conroy–
Arturo Benevida / Dr. Grebe / Mr. Wickens
Arturo Benevida / Dr. Grebe / Mr. Wickens
Less 75,307
4
1958–1959
Nancy Wickwire–
Jean Ferrier / Pamela Hampshire
Jean Ferrier / Pamela Hampshire
Less 142,725
4
1960–1963
Keir Dullea–
David March / Donald 'Don' McCabe
David March / Donald 'Don' McCabe
Less 4,206
4
1961–1963
Sally Brophy–
Kitty / Miss Maddox
Kitty / Miss Maddox
Less 83,951
3
1956–1962
Conrad Janis–
Bill Adams / Peter / Tap-Out
Bill Adams / Peter / Tap-Out
Less 17,024
3
1955–1960
Gaby Rodgers–
Annette O'Hara / Jeanne / Sophie
Annette O'Hara / Jeanne / Sophie
Less 82,975
3
1957–1962
Betty Sinclair–
Mary Jones / Mrs. Dabney / Mrs. Mickleman
Mary Jones / Mrs. Dabney / Mrs. Mickleman
Less 584,169
3
1953–1963
Anthony Kemble-Cooper–
Binkie Bellairs / Hamish McNair / Talbot
Binkie Bellairs / Hamish McNair / Talbot
Less 734,179
3
1953–1961
Charles Sanford–
Himself - Orchestra Leader / Himself - orchestra leader
Himself - Orchestra Leader / Himself - orchestra leader
Less 3,274,780
3
1959–1960
John Colicos–
Dr. Steve Bruchesi / Edmund Hobert
Dr. Steve Bruchesi / Edmund Hobert
Less 13,971
3
1960–1963